2.13 - Cromwell in Ireland & Scotland
Key facts and dates
The mid-17th century saw major Royalist rebellions in Ireland and Scotland against English parliamentary control, following the execution of Charles I. These uprisings aimed to install his son, Charles II, as king, but were crushed by Oliver Cromwell's forces, leading to significant changes in land ownership and governance.
Timeline of key events
- 1649 – Cromwell captures Drogheda and Wexford in Ireland, leading to massacres and surrenders.
- 1649 – Charles (future Charles II) proclaimed King of Scotland, sparking a new revolt.
- June 1650 – Charles lands in Scotland and allies with Protestant Covenanters.
- September 1650 – Cromwell defeats Scots at the Battle of Dunbar.
- September 1651 – Charles invades England but is defeated at the Battle of Worcester; he escapes to France.
The Irish revolt and Cromwell's campaign
The Irish rebellion had been ongoing since 1641, but after the execution of King Charles I in 1649, Parliament moved to suppress it decisively. The Irish, many of whom were Catholic, sought to place his son, Charles II, on the throne as king, hoping for the restoration of Catholic rights and lands, and challenging English parliamentary authority.
Reasons for the Irish rebellion
The rebels aimed to restore a Catholic-friendly ruler, opposing the Protestant-dominated English Parliament that had executed Charles I.
Cromwell's response and key battles
Parliament tasked Oliver Cromwell with suppressing the rebellion and securing English control. He led an army into Ireland to achieve this.
Key battles in Cromwell's Irish campaign:
- Capture of Drogheda (1649) – Cromwell's forces besieged and took the town, resulting in the killing of many inhabitants and captured soldiers who refused to surrender.
- Capture of Wexford (1649) – Similar violence occurred here, with people killed for resisting.
- Surrenders of other towns – Many Irish towns gave up, and Cromwell spared their inhabitants.
This campaign effectively brought much of Ireland under English parliamentary control, but it came at a high human cost.
Consequences of the Irish rebellion for land and religion
The suppression of the Irish revolt led to major changes in land distribution and religious practices. These measures aimed to punish rebels and strengthen Protestant influence, reshaping Irish society.
Land confiscation and resettlement
- Transfer to Protestants – Lands owned by Irish Catholic rebels were transferred to Protestants, including Cromwell's soldiers.
- Banishment of Irish people – Many Irish Catholics were banished to the west of Ireland.
Religious restrictions
The practice of Catholicism was forbidden.
The Scottish rebellion and its spread to England
The rebellion that started in Ireland soon influenced events in Scotland, where Royalist sympathies also ran high. Charles, son of the executed king, became a focal point for opposition to English parliamentary rule.
Proclamation and alliance in Scotland
- Charles proclaimed king (1649) – Scots declared Charles King of Scotland.
- Landing and deal with Covenanters (June 1650) – Charles arrived in Scotland and made a deal with the Protestant Covenanters to get their support.
Cromwell's campaign and defeats
Oliver Cromwell shifted his attention north, leading an English army into Scotland to crush the rebellion.
Key battles in Cromwell's Scottish campaign:
- Battle of Dunbar (1650) – Cromwell's forces defeated the Scots, weakening their position.
- Invasion of England and Battle of Worcester (1651) – Charles led his army into England but was defeated at Worcester.
- Charles's escape – Charles fled to France.
English forces occupied large parts of Scotland.
Debates about whether Cromwell's actions were too cruel
Cromwell's handling of the Irish rebellion, particularly the events at Drogheda and Wexford, has sparked ongoing historical debate. Some view his actions as excessively harsh, while others argue they were typical of the era's warfare.
| Cromwell's actions were excessively harsh | Cromwell's actions were typical for the time |
|---|---|
| The massacres at Drogheda and Wexford have never been forgiven. | Cromwell generally ordered that civilians should not be harmed and offered towns the chance to surrender. |
| Critics argued he showed less mercy than necessary, and many Irish Catholics were killed or lost their land. | Killing opponents, even unarmed ones, was common; when towns surrendered, he spared the inhabitants. |
A key source from Cromwell himself describes the Battle of Drogheda:
"I believe we put to the sword the whole number of defendants. I do not think 30 of them escaped. Those that did are in safe custody waiting to be sent to the Barbadoes. I am persuaded this is the righteous judgement of God..."
This letter, written on 17 September 1649, reflects his belief that the violence was justified as divine retribution.