2.15 - Impact of Revolution: Ireland & Scotland
Key facts and dates
The Glorious Revolution of 1688-89 led to significant conflict in Ireland and Scotland, where Catholic supporters of James II clashed with Protestant forces loyal to William of Orange. These events resulted in bloody defeats, land losses, and lasting divisions.
Timeline of key events
- 1688 – James II escapes to France after William and Mary take the throne.
- 1689 – James raises an army in Ireland and attacks Protestant Londonderry; in Scotland, Jacobites win the Battle of Killiecrankie but lose their leader, Viscount Dundee.
- 1690 – William's forces defeat James at the Battle of the Boyne in Ireland; James flees to France.
- 1691 – Irish Catholics surrender at Limerick, leading to the Treaty of Limerick, which is later broken.
- 1692 – Massacre of the MacDonald clan at Glencoe in Scotland for refusing to support William.
- 1752 – Britain adopts the Gregorian calendar, shifting the commemoration of the Battle of the Boyne to 12 July.
Overview of the Glorious Revolution's effects on Ireland and Scotland
The Glorious Revolution, which replaced the Catholic King James II with the Protestant William of Orange and Mary in 1688-89, had far-reaching consequences beyond England. In Ireland and Scotland, where many people were Catholic and loyal to James, it sparked violent rebellions and deep divisions. These regions experienced bloody conflicts, as supporters of James (known as Jacobites) resisted the new Protestant rulers, leading to defeats, land confiscations, and ongoing resentment.
James II's rebellion in Ireland
After losing the throne, James II sought to regain power by rallying support in Ireland, where his Catholic faith aligned with the majority population. This led to a short-lived rebellion that highlighted religious tensions between Catholics and Protestants.
How James organised the rebellion
- Journey to Ireland - James escaped to France in 1688, where the French king provided him with 7000 soldiers; he then travelled to Ireland to raise an army among Catholic supporters.
- Support from Irish Catholics - Catholics had been treated favourably under James's rule, including greater religious freedoms, which encouraged them to back his campaign against the Protestant William.
- Initial successes and ultimate defeat - James's forces made early gains, but they were decisively beaten by William's army at the Battle of the Boyne in July 1690, forcing James to flee back to France.
Main events of the Irish rebellion
The rebellion unfolded through a series of key confrontations and sieges, culminating in Catholic surrender. These events demonstrated the military superiority of William's forces and the challenges faced by James's supporters.
Sequence of major events
- 1689 – James's army besieged the Protestant city of Londonderry, attempting to capture it as a strategic base.
- 1690 – William's troops seized Belfast and advanced to victory at the Battle of the Boyne, scattering James's forces.
- 1691 – The Catholics lost control of Limerick, their last major stronghold, and were forced to accept defeat.
Social and economic consequences for Irish Catholics
The defeat in Ireland led to severe penalties for Catholics, including massive land losses and broken promises of tolerance. This deepened divisions and contributed to long-term Protestant dominance.
Key impacts on land and rights
- Loss of land ownership - In 1640, Catholics held 60% of Irish land, but by 1689, this had fallen to just 20%, with much transferred to Protestant hands during the Glorious Revolution and earlier periods like the Interregnum (the republican rule after the English Civil War).
- The Treaty of Limerick - Signed in 1691, this agreement promised religious freedoms and the return of some lands to Catholics, but these terms were quickly violated, earning Limerick the nickname "City of the Broken Treaty".
- Ongoing Protestant commemorations - Some Protestants in modern Ireland, known as Orangemen, celebrate William's victory at the Battle of the Boyne annually on 12 July (adjusted from the original 1 July date due to the 1752 calendar change from Julian to Gregorian).
Opposition to William in Scotland
In Scotland, reactions to the Glorious Revolution were divided along religious and regional lines. While some Protestants pushed for further reforms, Catholic groups mounted armed resistance, leading to conflicts in the Highlands.
Divisions in Scottish society
- Presbyterian support for change - Extreme Protestants, known as Presbyterians, backed the revolution and wanted it to extend further; their church system, called the Kirk, emphasised strict Protestant principles.
- Catholic Highlanders' loyalty to James - Highland clans, who were mostly Catholic, supported James II and were willing to fight against William, viewing him as an illegitimate ruler.
- Challenges of organisation - The Highlanders, organised into family-based clans, suffered from internal rivalries and lacked unity, which weakened their efforts; William exploited this by bribing some chiefs to switch sides.
Key battles and the Massacre of Glencoe
Scottish resistance featured early victories but ultimately faltered due to leadership losses and brutal reprisals. These events highlighted the violent nature of the conflict and William's determination to secure control.
Major conflicts in Scotland
- Battle of Killiecrankie - In July 1689, James's supporters, led by the 1st Viscount of Dundee, defeated William's forces in the central Highlands; however, Dundee's death in the battle severely undermined the Jacobite cause.
- Massacre of Glencoe - In 1692, William's supporters slaughtered members of the MacDonald clan in the western Highlands while they slept; the MacDonalds had refused to pledge allegiance to William, and the massacre was used by his opponents to portray him as ruthless.
- Consequences of the massacre - This event increased William's unpopularity in northern Scotland, where many Jacobites continued to oppose him even after his overall victory.