1.10 - Long-Term Causes & Historical Grievances
Key facts and dates
Long-term causes and historical grievances have shaped the conditions for many global conflicts, from world wars to regional disputes. These underlying tensions, often spanning decades or centuries, created fertile ground for violence when combined with immediate triggers. The following timeline highlights pivotal events and periods that contributed to major wars.
Timeline of key events
- 1870-1871 – Franco-Prussian War sows seeds of Franco-German antagonism, influencing WWI and WWII.
- 1916 – Sykes-Picot Agreement by Britain and France redraws Middle Eastern borders, impacting Iran-Iraq and Gulf Wars.
- 1917-1922 – Russian Civil War leaves a legacy of tension, affecting the WWII Eastern Front.
- 1947 – Partition of India creates Indo-Pakistan tensions, leading to multiple wars.
- 1389 (historical memory) – Battle of Kosovo used by Serbian leaders in the 1990s to fuel nationalist grievances.
Deep-rooted historical rivalries and their role in major conflicts
Many wars have their origins in long-standing rivalries between nations, where historical antagonism created a persistent state of tension. These rivalries often stemmed from territorial disputes, military defeats, or cultural differences, building resentment over generations.
Franco-German antagonism
Originating from the Franco-Prussian War (1870-1871), where Germany's victory led to the loss of Alsace-Lorraine to Germany, France harboured deep resentment. This bitterness contributed significantly to the outbreak of both World War I and World War II, as France sought to reclaim lost territory and prestige.
Austro-Russian rivalry in the Balkans
Before World War I, the Austro-Hungarian Empire and Russia competed for influence in the Balkan region. Their conflicting interests over Slavic populations and territorial control heightened tensions, playing a key role in the complex web of alliances and conflicts that triggered the war.
Sino-Japanese tensions
Dating back to the Meiji period in the late 19th century, Japan's modernisation and expansionist ambitions clashed with China's regional dominance. These tensions escalated through the early 20th century, culminating in full-scale conflict by 1937 with the Second Sino-Japanese War.
The impact of colonial legacies on modern wars
Colonial policies and decisions by European powers have left lasting scars on many regions, creating artificial borders and ethnic divisions that continue to fuel conflicts. These legacies often ignored local histories and identities, planting the seeds for future violence.
Sykes-Picot Agreement (1916)
This secret agreement between Britain and France divided the Ottoman Empire's Middle Eastern territories into spheres of influence, creating artificial borders. These boundaries disregarded ethnic and tribal affiliations, contributing to conflicts like the Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988) and the Gulf Wars (1990-1991, 2003).
Portuguese and Belgian colonial policies in Africa
In countries like Angola and the Congo, colonial rule exacerbated ethnic tensions by favouring certain groups over others or drawing arbitrary borders. These divisions led to civil wars and instability after independence, as rival factions vied for power.
French colonialism
In Algeria, French rule from 1830 created deep social and economic inequalities, sparking the Algerian War of Independence (1954-1962). Similarly, in Vietnam, French exploitation and suppression of local culture fuelled resistance movements, eventually leading to the First Indochina War (1946-1954).
Unresolved conflicts and their lasting consequences
Some conflicts were never fully resolved, leaving lingering issues that resurfaced in later wars. These unresolved disputes often involved ideological, territorial, or political divisions that simmered beneath the surface for years.
Russian Civil War (1917-1922)
The ideological divide between the Bolsheviks and anti-communist forces created a legacy of bitterness. This tension influenced Soviet strategies and alliances during World War II, particularly on the Eastern Front, where old grievances shaped military and political decisions.
Chinese Civil War (1927-1949)
Suspended during World War II to fight a common enemy (Japan), the conflict between the Nationalists and Communists resumed in 1946. This resumption prolonged instability in China, shaping its modern political landscape.
Indo-Pakistan tensions
The 1947 partition of British India into India and Pakistan created immediate territorial disputes, particularly over Kashmir. This unresolved conflict led to multiple wars (1947-1948, 1965, 1971) and continues to generate friction between the two nations.
Militarism as a long-term cause of war
Militarism, defined as the belief in building strong armed forces and using military solutions to achieve national goals, has been a recurring factor in global conflicts. It often intertwined with political power, shaping national policies towards aggression.
Prussian militarism before WWI
In Germany, the Prussian tradition of a strong military permeated politics, with the army holding significant influence over government decisions. This culture glorified war and prioritised military preparedness, contributing to the aggressive stance that led to World War I.
Japanese military culture and bushido code
Rooted in the samurai tradition, the bushido code emphasised honour and loyalty through military prowess. This mindset drove Japan's expansionist policies in the 1930s, leading to invasions in China and broader conflict in the Pacific during World War II.
Pakistani military's role in politics
Since Pakistan's independence, the military has frequently dominated political life, often justifying interventions through security concerns with India. This militaristic influence has sustained a state of readiness for conflict, impacting wars with India over Kashmir and other issues.
Economic changes and resource competition as conflict drivers
Economic transformations and the competition for scarce resources have often acted as underlying causes of war. As nations industrialised or globalised, their need for resources intensified, sometimes pushing them into conflict.
Industrialisation and new weapons in WWI
The industrial revolution enabled mass production of advanced weaponry, such as machine guns and artillery, escalating the scale and destructiveness of World War I. This technological race for superiority fuelled arms build-ups and heightened tensions.
Globalisation and resource competition
As global trade expanded, control over resources like oil became critical. The Chaco War (1932-1935) between Bolivia and Paraguay was driven by disputes over oil-rich territory, while the Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988) partly stemmed from competition over oil reserves and waterway access.
Manipulation of historical memory and grievances
Historical events and perceived injustices have often been exploited by leaders to justify aggression or mobilise populations for war. By invoking past grievances, political figures could stoke nationalist sentiments and rally support.
Nazi use of the Treaty of Versailles
After World War I, the harsh terms of the Treaty of Versailles (1919) humiliated Germany by imposing territorial losses and economic reparations. Nazi propaganda under Hitler exploited this resentment, portraying the treaty as a national betrayal to justify rearmament and territorial expansion.
Serbian use of the Battle of Kosovo (1389)
In the 1990s, Serbian leaders referenced the medieval Battle of Kosovo as a symbol of national struggle against external enemies. This historical narrative was used to fuel ethnic tensions during the Yugoslav Wars, contributing to violence in the Balkans.
Iraqi claims to Kuwait
Leading up to the 1990 Gulf War, Iraq under Saddam Hussein invoked historical claims that Kuwait was once part of the Ottoman province of Basra. This narrative was used to justify the invasion, framing it as a reclamation of rightful territory rather than aggression.