1.10 - Storm on the Island
Context
Political and historical context
- The poem was published in 1966, at the beginning of 'The Troubles', a period of violent political and sectarian conflict in Northern Ireland that lasted for around 30 years.
- The poem's title contains a pun on 'Stormont', the name of Northern Ireland's Parliament buildings.
- This links the natural storm in the poem to the political "storm" of the conflict, suggesting the poem is an allegory [symbolic extended metaphor] for the political tensions of the time.
Biographical context
- Seamus Heaney grew up in a rural community in Northern Ireland and was familiar with both the power of nature and the political violence surrounding him.
- The poem reflects the experience of ordinary communities trapped by a conflict they cannot control, forced to simply endure the fear and violence.
- Heaney often wrote about the connection between the natural landscape and human experience.
Overview
Storm on the Island in a nutshell
- What literally happens in the poem: The speaker describes how their island community prepares for a powerful storm, feeling safe at first, but then becoming terrified by the invisible violence of the wind.
- Context and significance: Heaney uses the storm as an extended metaphor for the political conflict of 'The Troubles' in Northern Ireland, exploring themes of fear, helplessness, and the conflict between humanity and nature.
- Key techniques and approach: The poet uses a conversational tone, a single solid stanza, and a semantic field [group of words linked by theme] of warfare to create a sense of immediate, inescapable threat.
✓ Poem text verified against source
Translation and Heaney's intent
Lines 1-5
"We are prepared: we build our houses squat,
Sink walls in rock and roof them with good slate.
The wizened earth has never troubled us
With hay, so as you can see, there are no stacks
Or stooks that can be lost."
Translation
- The speaker begins by confidently stating that the community is ready for the storm.
- They have built strong, low houses with walls sunk into the rock and heavy slate roofs.
- The land is barren and rocky ("wizened"), so they don't grow crops like hay, meaning there are no haystacks to be blown away.
Heaney's intention
- The collective pronoun "We" establishes a sense of a community united against the storm.
- The confident, matter-of-fact tone and end-stopped lines [lines ending with punctuation] create an initial feeling of security and control.
- Heaney presents the islanders as practical and experienced, believing they have done everything possible to protect themselves from the power of nature. This confidence is later shown to be misplaced.
Lines 5-10
"Nor are there trees
Which might prove company when it blows full
Blast: you know what I mean - leaves and branches
Can raise a tragic chorus in a gale
So that you can listen to the thing you fear
Forgetting that it pummels your house too."
Translation
- The speaker explains that the island has no trees, which could offer a sense of "company".
- Trees can sound like a "tragic chorus" in a storm, making the wind seem audible and understandable.
- Without trees, the islanders have no natural shelter and cannot be distracted from the direct physical assault of the storm on their homes.
Heaney's intention
- The direct address "you know what I mean" creates a conversational and personal tone, drawing the reader into the experience.
- The personification [giving human qualities to objects] of the trees raising a "tragic chorus" suggests that nature can sometimes provide a warning or context for danger.
- The absence of trees highlights the island's complete isolation and vulnerability to the direct, unmediated force of the wind.
Lines 11-16
"But there are no trees, no natural shelter.
You might think that the sea is company,
Exploding comfortably down on the cliffs
But no: when it begins, the flung spray hits
The very windows, spits like a tame cat
Turned savage."
Translation
- The speaker repeats that there is no natural protection on the island.
- The sea might seem like a comforting presence, with waves "exploding comfortably" on the cliffs below.
- However, this sense of comfort is false. When the storm truly starts, the sea spray hits the windows and is compared to a domestic cat suddenly becoming wild and violent.
Heaney's intention
- The line "But no:" marks the poem's volta [turning point], with the caesura [pause mid-line] creating an abrupt shift in tone from safety to fear.
- The oxymoron [contradictory terms] "exploding comfortably" shows the deceptive nature of the sea.
- The simile [comparison using 'like' or 'as'] "spits like a tame cat / Turned savage" is crucial. It shows how something familiar and seemingly safe can become a dangerous, unpredictable threat, mirroring how neighbours could turn on each other during 'The Troubles'.
✓ All quotations checked for accuracy
Lines 16-19
"We just sit tight while wind dives
And strafes invisibly. Space is a salvo.
We are bombarded by the empty air.
Strange, it is a huge nothing that we fear."
Translation
- The community is now passive and helpless, only able to "sit tight" as the wind attacks.
- The wind is described using military terms: it "dives" and "strafes" (attacks with gunfire from the air).
- The open space around them becomes a "salvo" (a simultaneous discharge of artillery), and they are "bombarded" by the air itself.
- The speaker concludes with the strange realisation that the thing they are so afraid of is invisible and intangible - a "huge nothing".
Heaney's intention
- Heaney uses a semantic field of warfare ("dives", "strafes", "salvo", "bombarded") to present the storm as a malicious, deliberate military assault.
- This extended metaphor directly links the power of nature to the political violence of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
- The paradox [a seemingly self-contradictory statement] in the final line, "a huge nothing", reveals the poem's central theme: The most terrifying threats are often invisible ones, like fear, political tension, or psychological pressure.
✓ Ending lines confirmed accurate
Writer's methods
Analysing form, structure, and language together is essential. These elements are deliberately chosen by the poet to shape the meaning of the poem and create specific effects, all linking back to the central themes and Heaney's purpose.
Form
The poem is written in blank verse, which is unrhymed iambic pentameter [a line with ten syllables in a pattern of unstressed then stressed].
| Theme | Evidence | Poet's intention |
|---|---|---|
| Fear and helplessness | Blank verse that mimics the rhythm of natural, everyday speech. | Heaney makes the speaker's account sound like a real, conversational story. This makes the terrifying experience feel more authentic, immediate, and believable for the reader. |
| Isolation and conflict | The poem is written as a dramatic monologue, with a first-person speaker ("We") addressing an unseen listener ("you"). | This form creates a personal and intimate tone. It draws the reader directly into the experience of the community, making them feel the shared sense of fear and entrapment. |
Structure
The poem's structure helps to build tension and reflects the islanders' experience of the storm.
| Theme | Evidence | Poet's intention |
|---|---|---|
| Isolation and vulnerability | The poem is written in one single, solid stanza. | The block of text looks secure and imposing on the page, like the islanders' "squat" houses. This form reflects the community huddled together, trying to remain solid against the storm's relentless attack. The lack of breaks can also feel claustrophobic, trapping the reader in the experience. |
| Power of nature | The volta (turning point) is marked by a caesura in the line "But no: when it begins...". | This abrupt pause dramatically shifts the poem's tone from one of confidence to one of immediate danger. Heaney uses this structural break to show how quickly a sense of security can be shattered by an external force. |
| The relentless storm | Frequent use of enjambment [line runs on to the next without punctuation] makes the poem flow quickly. | The lines running into one another reflect the constant, unstoppable onslaught of the storm. This technique mirrors the inescapable nature of the wind and the fear it causes. |
Language
Heaney's language choices, particularly his use of military and animalistic imagery, are central to the poem's meaning.
| Theme | Evidence | Poet's intention |
|---|---|---|
| Conflict | A semantic field of warfare is used: "dives", "strafes", "salvo", "bombarded". | Heaney uses this military metaphor to connect the natural storm to political violence. This suggests that to those under siege, the attack feels deliberate, malicious, and inescapable, whether from nature or from other people. |
| Power of nature | The simile "spits like a tame cat / Turned savage". | This comparison shows how quickly the familiar can become a threat. The domestic and harmless "tame cat" becomes a violent, unpredictable force, reflecting how civil conflict can turn communities and neighbours against one another. |
| Fear and helplessness | The final line contains the oxymoron and paradox "huge nothing". | The fear comes from an invisible, intangible force that cannot be fought. Heaney's final message is that psychological fear and unseen threats are more powerful and terrifying than any physical danger. |
| Confidence and preparation | The use of plain, solid language at the start, such as "squat", "sink walls in rock", and "good slate". | The simple, strong verbs and adjectives reflect the community's belief in their physical preparations. This language of security contrasts sharply with the language of violence and fear used later in the poem. |
What to compare it to
Effective comparison involves exploring how poets use different methods to explore similar ideas or themes. Focus on connecting the poets' purposes and how their choices of form, structure, and language create particular effects.
Suggested comparisons
- Storm on the Island and The Prelude: Stealing the Boat - Both poems explore the terrifying power of nature and its psychological impact on humans.
- Storm on the Island and Exposure - Both poems show how an invisible or natural enemy (weather) can be more damaging than a physical one, and both explore feelings of helplessness.
Storm on the Island and The Prelude: Stealing the Boat
Comparison in a nutshell
Both Heaney and Wordsworth explore how the power of nature can overwhelm human confidence and leave a lasting psychological impact. However, Heaney focuses on a shared, communal experience of an external attack, while Wordsworth describes a solitary, personal experience of a haunting internalised terror.
Similarities
Point
Both poets present nature as a powerful, aggressive force that challenges humanity's sense of control and security.
Evidence and explanation
| Storm on the Island | The Prelude: Stealing the Boat |
|---|---|
| Heaney uses a semantic field of warfare, describing the wind as it "dives / And strafes invisibly". This military metaphor presents nature as a deliberate, hostile enemy attacking the community. | Similarly, Wordsworth personifies the mountain as a monstrous being. The peak "Upreared its head" and "Strode after me", suggesting it is a living thing with a conscious will to intimidate and pursue the boy. |
| The community initially feels secure, having built their houses "squat" and strong. This confidence is shattered, showing human preparations are futile against nature's power. | Likewise, the boy is initially "Proud of his skill" as he rows the boat. His arrogance is quickly replaced by terror when confronted by the "huge peak", demonstrating nature's ability to humble human pride. |
Differences
Point
While both poems explore fear, Heaney presents it as a communal, external threat, whereas Wordsworth depicts it as a solitary, psychological haunting.
Evidence and explanation
| Storm on the Island | The Prelude: Stealing the Boat |
|---|---|
| Heaney uses the collective pronoun "We" throughout, emphasising a shared experience ("We are prepared", "We just sit tight"). The threat is an immediate, physical assault from outside. | In contrast, Wordsworth uses the first-person singular "I", focusing on a deeply personal and individual experience. The fear becomes internalised, affecting his mind for days afterwards ("a trouble to my dreams"). |
| The conflict is presented as an ongoing battle with an invisible enemy, reflecting the political context of 'The Troubles'. The fear is immediate and present. | Conversely, the conflict in Wordsworth's poem is a transformative moment that leads to a profound psychological change. The experience is in the past, but its impact is lasting and shapes his understanding of the world. |
Endings comparison
Point
Heaney's poem ends with a philosophical statement about the nature of fear itself, while Wordsworth's ending focuses on the long-lasting psychological trauma caused by the encounter with nature.
Evidence and explanation
| Storm on the Island | The Prelude: Stealing the Boat |
|---|---|
| The poem concludes with the oxymoron "it is a huge nothing that we fear". This ending shifts from the physical storm to the abstract, psychological concept of fear, suggesting the most powerful enemy is an unseen one. | Wordsworth's poem ends by describing the lasting impact on the narrator's mind. For days, his thoughts were haunted by "huge and mighty forms" that "were a trouble to my dreams". The ending focuses on personal trauma rather than a universal truth. |
Storm on the Island and Exposure
Comparison in a nutshell
Both Heaney and Owen explore the power of nature as an enemy that is more dangerous and terrifying than any human foe. Heaney focuses on the acute, violent terror of a sudden attack, while Owen describes the slow, draining despair of a relentless, monotonous wait.
Similarities
Point
Both poets personify the weather, presenting it as a conscious, malicious enemy that is actively attacking the speakers.
Evidence and explanation
| Storm on the Island | Exposure |
|---|---|
| Heaney uses military language to describe the wind's assault, as it "dives / And strafes invisibly". This portrays nature as a modern, machine-like enemy engaged in a targeted attack. | Similarly, Owen personifies the weather as an army. Dawn is a "melancholy army" that "Attacks once more in ranks on shivering ranks of grey", suggesting the weather is an organised, relentless enemy force. |
| The speakers are completely passive and helpless against the onslaught of nature. The islanders can only "sit tight" and endure the storm's bombardment. | Likewise, the soldiers in Exposure can do nothing against the cold but wait. The poem repeatedly states "But nothing happens", highlighting their powerlessness and the futility of their situation. |
Differences
Point
Heaney's poem builds a sense of immediate, violent tension through its structure, whereas Owen uses a repetitive, cyclical structure to create a feeling of endless, draining monotony.
Evidence and explanation
| Storm on the Island | Exposure |
|---|---|
| Heaney uses a single, solid stanza with frequent enjambment. This creates a relentless, claustrophobic feeling, mirroring the intense and inescapable violence of the brief storm. | In contrast, Owen uses eight five-line stanzas with a regular rhyme scheme (ABBAC) and a repeating final line, "But nothing happens". This cyclical structure reflects the repetitive, boring, and unending nature of the soldiers' suffering. |
| The conflict in Storm on the Island is active and loud, described with dynamic verbs like "exploding", "spits", and "pummels". The poem captures the noise and energy of the attack. | Owen's poem, however, is characterised by silence and stillness ("the night is silent"). The suffering is slow and quiet, focusing on the psychological decay caused by waiting, where even bullets are "Less deadly than the air". |
Endings comparison
Point
The ending of Storm on the Island offers a philosophical conclusion about the nature of fear, while the ending of Exposure provides a bleak and hopeless vision of ongoing, pointless death.
Evidence and explanation
| Storm on the Island | Exposure |
|---|---|
| The final line, "Strange, it is a huge nothing that we fear", concludes with a moment of intellectual realisation. It is a paradoxical statement that invites reflection on psychological versus physical threats. | The final stanza of Exposure presents a grim, literal scene of death. The "burying-party" pauses over frozen bodies where "All their eyes are ice". The poem ends with the hopeless refrain "But nothing happens", suggesting their deaths have changed nothing. |