11.3 - Evaluating & Improving a Method
Sources of error and improvements
- A source of error is something in the method that makes a reading less accurate.
- An improvement must directly target and reduce that specific error.
Common errors and their fixes
| Source of error | Improvement that fixes it |
|---|---|
| Heat lost to the surroundings in a temperature-change experiment | Insulate around the cup, fit a lid on top, stir the mixture, and keep it away from draughts |
| Parallax error when reading a scale (e.g. on a gas syringe or measuring cylinder) | Put your eye level with the scale and read it straight on |
| Judging a titration end point colour change by eye | Add the last few cm3 drop by drop while swirling constantly, and stand the flask on a white tile |
Anomalies and repeats
- An anomalous result is a result that doesn't fit the pattern of the others.
- When calculating a mean, identify any anomalous results and exclude them so they don't skew the average.
Why repeat readings and calculate a mean?
- It helps you identify anomalous results.
- It reduces the effect of random errors, so the mean is likely to be closer to the true value.
Representative samples
- A representative sample is used when the material being tested varies across different locations, times, or batches.
- For example, test water samples taken from several points along a river, or test multiple tablets from across a batch of medicine.
Concordant titres
- Concordant titres are results that agree closely with each other, usually within 0.10 cm3.
- Only the mean of the concordant titres is used in titration calculations; any non-concordant titres are left out.
TermDefinition
Source of error
Anomalous result
Representative sample
Concordant