13.11 - Common Question Types
"Suggest why / explain why / state why" a step is done
- When asked why an experimental step is carried out, identify what would go wrong or be lost if the step were skipped.
- The credited reason is the consequence the step prevents or ensures, not a restatement of the step itself.
- Frame your answer as: [the step happens] so that [something specific is kept accurate, fair, or complete].
Common steps and their reasons
| The step | Why it's done |
|---|---|
| The first few bubbles of gas aren't collected | Air in the apparatus must be flushed out first, so the collected gas isn't diluted with air |
| A mixture is stirred while being heated | Keeps the temperature and concentration even throughout, preventing hot spots near the flame |
| A conical flask is placed on a white tile (or dark paper) for a titration | Makes a colour change in a pale or colourless solution easier to see against the background |
| Small pieces of a solid catalyst are used instead of one large piece | Smaller pieces have a larger surface area for the same mass, making the reaction faster |
| An experiment is repeated and results are compared | Allows anomalous results to be identified and a mean to be calculated, making the result more reliable |
Comparing two experiments or results
To explain differences or similarities between two experiments, find what changed between them and connect that variable directly to the result.
The general pattern
- Identify what changed and what was kept constant between the experiments.
- State the effect of the variable, linking it to the specific observation or measurement asked about.
- If the results are the same, explain why the variable did not affect the outcome (e.g. a reagent was already in excess, or the limiting reagent was unchanged).
Worked examples
- Why a volumetric pipette can't measure the aluminium chloride - The volume of aluminium chloride varies between experiments, whereas a volumetric pipette only delivers one fixed volume.
- Why distilled water is increased as another reagent is decreased - Keeps the total volume of liquid constant, ensuring any difference in results is caused solely by changing the reagent concentration.
- Why the same mass of precipitate forms in several experiments - In those experiments, one reagent is in excess, so the amount of precipitate is determined by the limiting reagent, which is kept at a fixed amount.
Identifying a gas or substance from a description
Match the properties, observations, or behaviour in the description directly to the test, gas, or substance they indicate.
Worked examples
- A colourless gas that relights a glowing splint - Oxygen (O2).
- A pungent, alkaline gas that turns damp red litmus blue - Ammonia (NH3).
- Gas produced when heating hydrated aluminium chloride - Hydrogen chloride (HCl) or steam (H2O).
Ruling substances out
- A negative test result rules specific substances out rather than naming what is present.
- Example - No precipitate forming on adding dilute nitric acid followed by aqueous silver nitrate shows that chloride, bromide, and iodide ions are not present.
Key points to remember
How were these notes?