1.5 - Choosing the Right Legal Structure
Factors to consider when choosing a business structure
Selecting an appropriate structure is a key decision when establishing a business, as it affects liability, control, and overall operations. Although structures can be altered later, initial choices often reflect the business's size and goals.
Key decisions in business structure selection
- Liability type - Businesses must choose between limited liability, where owners' personal assets are protected from business debts, and unlimited liability, where owners are personally responsible for all debts.
- Control level - Entrepreneurs need to decide how much authority they want to retain over decisions, with some structures allowing more individual control than others.
Characteristics of different business structures
Smaller businesses, such as sole traders or partnerships, usually feature unlimited liability, placing personal finances at risk. In contrast, larger businesses often adopt limited liability structures like Ltd or PLC to safeguard owners. Sole traders and Ltd companies typically offer greater control to the founder compared to partnerships or PLCs, where decision-making may be shared or influenced by external shareholders.
How business structures can change over time
Business structures are not fixed and can evolve as the organisation grows or circumstances change. This flexibility allows adaptation to new opportunities or needs, such as expanding operations or attracting investment.
Reasons for changing business structure
- Growth and investment - A sole trader might transition to a partnership if an individual, such as a family member or employee, invests capital in exchange for profit shares.
- Incorporation for protection - As a business expands, sole traders or partnerships may incorporate to gain limited liability, reducing personal financial risk.
- Going public - Incorporated businesses might issue public shares to raise significant funds, evolving into PLCs, which is common for very large organisations aiming for substantial growth.
Most major businesses operate as PLCs due to their ability to access public investment.
The nature of not-for-profit organisations
Not-for-profit organisations focus on objectives beyond generating profits for owners, prioritising societal or community benefits instead. They differ from traditional businesses by reinvesting any surplus rather than distributing it as personal gains.
Core features of not-for-profit organisations
- Profit handling - These organisations aim to generate sufficient income to cover expenses, with any excess reinvested into operations or used for community initiatives.
- Diversity in scale and purpose - They vary widely in size and goals, ranging from small local groups to large international bodies, all driven by non-financial missions.
- Management challenges - Running these organisations can be difficult due to unpredictable funding and reliance on volunteers rather than full-time staff, leading to instability in resources and planning.
Types and funding of not-for-profits
Not-for-profit organisations include various forms, each with distinct approaches to funding and societal impact. Many benefit from special statuses that provide financial advantages.
Main types of not-for-profit organisations
Charities:
- Often granted charitable status, which offers tax exemptions and access to specific grants.
- They must adhere to strict regulations, making setup complex.
- They primarily rely on donations and grants, which can result in inconsistent income.
Social enterprises:
- These operate like commercial businesses by selling goods or services but direct profits towards social benefits.
- They depend less on donations and more on trading revenue, providing greater financial stability.
Both charities and social enterprises aim to improve society.
Legal structures for not-for-profit organisations
Not-for-profit organisations can adopt various legal forms to suit their needs, balancing ease of setup with liability protection. These structures determine how risks are managed and how the organisation operates legally.
Options for legal structures in not-for-profits
- Unincorporated association - Simple to establish but exposes managers to unlimited liability, meaning personal assets could be at risk if issues arise.
- Incorporated organisation - Provides limited liability for those running it, protecting personal finances while allowing the entity to function as a separate legal body.
- Limited by guarantee - Members agree to contribute a fixed sum if the organisation faces insolvency, offering a safeguard without share-based ownership.