9.2 - Accuracy, Precision & Error
Accuracy and precision
Accuracy and precision sound alike, but a set of results can have one without the other:
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Close to the true value |
| Precise | The repeated readings are close to each other (a small spread) |
Precise doesn't mean accurate
- A precise result is not always accurate.
- Example: weigh a 50.0 g mass on a balance that hasn't been set to zero, and you might read 52.0 g, 52.1 g, and 52.0 g.
- Those readings are precise because they barely differ - but none is accurate, because every one is about 2 g too high.
Resolution of an instrument
- An instrument that reads to more decimal places, such as a balance reading to 0.01 g rather than 0.1 g, has a higher resolution - the smallest change it can detect.
- Say "higher resolution" for an instrument, not "more precise". Precise describes a set of readings that cluster closely, not a single reading.
Repeatable and reproducible
- Both terms describe results that come out similar when the investigation is done again.
- The difference is who repeats it, and what stays the same.
The two terms
- Repeatable - You get similar results when you repeat the investigation yourself, with the same method and the same equipment.
- Reproducible - Someone else gets similar results, or you get them using a different method or different equipment.
Reproducible results give more confidence than repeatable ones, because a similar result from a different set-up rules out a fault peculiar to one person or one piece of equipment.
Random and systematic error
Two kinds of error affect measurements, and each one does something different:
- Random error - An unpredictable difference between readings, for example from slight differences in judgement when reading a scale. Reduce it by taking repeats and finding the mean.
- Systematic error - A fault that shifts every reading by the same amount in the same direction, such as a balance that is not set to zero. Taking a mean does not reduce it, because every reading is wrong in the same way.
Linking error to precision and accuracy
- Random error scatters your readings, so it harms precision - taking repeats and a mean reduces the effect of random error on your answer.
- Systematic error shifts every reading the same way, so it harms accuracy - no amount of repeating fixes it.
- So a set of results that is precise but not accurate points to a systematic error.
TermDefinition
Accurate
Precise
Resolution (measuring instrument)
Repeatable
Reproducible
Random error
Systematic error