2.9 - Subcultures & Hybridity
The hybrid nature of British culture
British culture is essentially a collection of subcultures, and is hybridised.
Key components of British cultural hybridity
- English influences - Values and norms.
- Celtic subcultures - Values and norms that originated in Scottish, Welsh, and Irish subcultures.
- Immigrant contributions - Elements from cultures whose members have lived in Britain for three or four generations.
Hybrid elements in spectacular youth subcultures
Many spectacular youth subcultures have a hybrid element, meaning they incorporate elements of other cultures, particularly subcultures of minority ethnic groups.
Examples of hybrid youth subcultures
- Mods in the 1960s - This group embraced Black soul music and adopted the 'cool' style of West Indian culture.
- Skinheads - Despite their association with racism, they incorporated influences from Jamaican ska and reggae music.
- Punks - Their music drew from political reggae produced in inner-city areas characterised by deprivation and racism.
White youth adopting Black culture ('white wannabes')
In the 1990s, some white young people began incorporating elements of Black hip-hop and rap culture into their identities. Sociologist Anoop Nayak explored this trend in his 2003 study.
Nayak's study (2003)
- Findings - Nayak (2003) observed that white youth in the 1990s adopted Black styles, such as hip-hop clothing, fist bumps as greetings, and slang terms. Nayak termed them 'white wannabes'.
- Conclusions - This hybridity spread to the music industry, with white rappers like Eminem in the USA and UK artists such as The Streets, Professor Green, and Kate Tempest gaining prominence.
Brasian identity among young British Asians
Sociologist Sanjiv Johal examined this in his 1998 work, arguing that young British Asians refuse to accept a subordinate place in either white-dominated society or their culture of origin.
Johal's study (1998)
- Hyper-ethnic style - They adopt a 'hyper-ethnic' style, an exaggerated form of their parents' culture, focused on watching Bollywood films and listening to Bhangra or Asian rap. This provides a form of 'empowerment through difference'.
- Brasian identity - Johal refers to middle-class professional young Asian people as 'Brasians' because their lifestyle often involves switching between two cultures:
- Asian culture: They respect their parents' wishes regarding arranged marriages.
- British culture: They may have aspirations for careers and a materialistic lifestyle that mirrors that of their white friends and peers.
Modern primitives as a hybrid neo-tribe
Modern primitives represent a contemporary subculture focused on body modification as a way to express identity. They are a good example of a hybrid neo-tribe. This group exemplifies hybridity by combining ancient practices with modern elements, creating a unique form of self-expression.
Key features of modern primitives
- Hybrid elements - They blend 'primitive' body art (e.g., tattoos and piercings inspired by indigenous groups like Amazonian peoples) with modern artistic styles, resulting in innovative designs.
- Purpose and motivations - Body modifications help individuals reclaim control in a fast-changing world, countering feelings of powerlessness.
Sociologists Vale and Juno analysed this in their 1989 study.
Vale and Juno's study (1989)
Vale and Juno (1989) claim that modern primitives use body modification (tattoos and piercings) to express identity, mixing non-industrial traditions with modern art aesthetics. These practices are a social reaction to feelings of powerlessness in a fast-changing world, helping individuals restore a sense of power and control by constructing a unique identity.