4.7 - Identities: Gender
The distinction between sex and gender
In sociology, the terms 'sex' and 'gender' refer to different concepts.
Key differences between sex and gender
- Biological basis of sex - Sex describes the biological differences between males and females, such as physical and genetic characteristics like chromosomes and reproductive anatomy.
- Social construction of gender - Gender is shaped by societal norms and expectations rather than biology.
- It refers to a person's internal sense of their own gender identity.
- This may or may not align with their assigned sex at birth.
- Ideas about gender are learned through socialisation and can differ across cultures and over time.
- While many identify as male or female, others fall outside these binary categories, viewing gender as a spectrum.
Sociologists prioritise gender over sex to understand inequalities in areas like education and work, which cannot be fully explained by biological differences.
The role of family as a primary agent of gender socialisation
Family plays a crucial role in early childhood as the primary agent of socialisation, teaching children the norms and values associated with traditional masculinity and femininity. Research by Ann Oakley (1974) highlights specific ways families shape gender identity.
Ways family influences gender socialisation
- Manipulation of self-image - Parents encourage behaviours seen as 'normal' for a child's sex, while discouraging those considered inappropriate. For instance, girls might be praised for being neat and quiet, while boys are encouraged to be active and bold.
- Canalisation of interests - Children are directed towards specific toys and activities based on gender. Boys might receive building sets or action figures, while girls are given dolls or pretend cooking sets, reinforcing traditional roles.
- Verbal appellation through language - Parents use gendered language to define appropriate behaviour, such as calling a girl 'sweetie' or a boy 'champ', embedding distinct expectations.
- Different household activities - Children are often involved in tasks aligned with gender stereotypes, like girls helping with cleaning indoors and boys assisting with outdoor chores like gardening.
The influence of school and media as secondary agents of gender socialisation
Beyond the family, secondary agents such as schools and media further shape gender roles by reinforcing societal expectations and stereotypes. These institutions build on the foundations laid during primary socialisation.
Gender socialisation in schools
- Differential treatment - Boys and girls are often treated differently in educational settings, with assumptions about how each should behave being passed on through interactions and expectations.
- Subject choice disparities - There are notable differences in the subjects chosen by genders at advanced levels, with boys more likely to opt for sciences like physics, while girls often prefer arts or humanities like literature.
- Reinforcement of stereotypes - Research by Skelton (2002) suggests that schools not only create gender stereotypes but also maintain those initially learned at home, embedding traditional norms further.
Gender socialisation through media
- Portrayal of gender roles - Media often depicts males and females in stereotypical ways, such as showing women as dependent or in need of rescue by a dominant male figure in films.
- Reinforcement of femininity - Angela McRobbie (1978) noted that magazines aimed at teenage girls often focus on traditional feminine ideals, prioritising beauty and relationships over independence.
- Unrealistic ideals in advertising - Wolf (1990) argued that advertisements frequently present an unattainable 'perfect' image for women, suggesting their value lies in appearance for male approval.
- Cultural perpetuation of differences - Joan Smith (1997) highlighted how broader cultural narratives in media sustain and amplify gender distinctions.
The impact of gender stereotypes on employment opportunities
Gender stereotypes significantly influence opportunities and experiences in the workplace, often creating barriers based on traditional roles rather than individual capability.
Effects of gender stereotypes on employment
- Disparities in senior roles - Data from Social Trends 38 (2008) indicates that a higher percentage of men (around 19%) hold managerial or senior official positions compared to women (approximately 11%).
- Barriers in male-dominated fields - Women often face challenges reaching top positions in professions traditionally seen as 'male', such as judicial roles where men remain the majority.
Changing gender roles for males and females
Over recent decades, gender roles have undergone significant transformation, reflecting shifts in societal attitudes and economic conditions for both females and males.
Evolving roles for females
- Shift in priorities - Research by Sue Sharpe, conducted initially in the 1970s and repeated in the 1990s, revealed a change in teenage girls' aspirations from valuing marriage and motherhood to prioritising career goals.
- Attitudes towards marriage - Diana Gittins (1993) pointed to rising divorce rates as evidence of women's changing views, showing less tolerance for unsatisfactory relationships and a move away from passive roles.
- Economic independence - More women entering the workforce and becoming primary earners in households signify a shift, often linked to the growth of office-based roles, described as the feminisation of the workforce.
- Rise in deviant behaviour - Ann Campbell (1984) observed an increase in non-traditional behaviours among females, such as participation in girl gangs, challenging conventional gender norms.
Evolving roles for males
- Shared domestic responsibilities - Jonathan Gershuny (1992) found that men are increasingly involved in childcare and housework, with the emergence of the 'new man' who participates in tasks like cooking and parenting.
- Rise of househusbands - There is a growing number of men staying at home to manage household duties while their partners work, often due to the decline of traditional male-dominated industries like manufacturing.
- Crisis in masculinity - Máirtín Mac an Ghaill (1994) suggests that these societal shifts have led to uncertainty among men about their roles, as traditional expectations are eroded and new roles require skills not historically emphasised in male socialisation.
- Feminisation of masculinity in media - Rutherford (1996) notes that media portrayals of men now often mirror traditionally female representations, such as being objects of visual admiration or marketed through cosmetics, indicating a blending of gender norms.
- Convergence of values - Wilkinson (1997) argues that male and female values are increasingly aligning, with identity for both genders being shaped more by consumption and leisure than by rigid notions of masculinity or femininity.