4.9 - Causes & Consequences of Unemployment
The main types of unemployment
Unemployment occurs when individuals who are able and willing to work cannot find suitable jobs. It can be categorised into three primary types: frictional, structural, and cyclical, each arising from different economic factors.
Frictional unemployment
Frictional unemployment happens when people are temporarily out of work while transitioning between jobs. It is often short-term and can be seen as a natural part of a dynamic labour market.
Types of frictional unemployment:
- Voluntary unemployment - Workers choose not to take available jobs because the pay or conditions do not meet their expectations, often influenced by the level of unemployment benefits compared to low-wage options.
- Search unemployment - Individuals take time to look for roles that better match their skills or offer higher salaries, rather than accepting the first opportunity.
- Casual unemployment - Applies to those in irregular employment, such as freelance workers, supply teachers, or seasonal gardeners, who experience gaps between assignments.
- Seasonal unemployment - Demand for labour varies with the time of year, impacting sectors like tourism, farming, and festive retail, where jobs peak during certain periods.
Structural unemployment
Structural unemployment stems from fundamental shifts in the economy that create a mismatch between available jobs and workers' abilities or locations. It often requires retraining or relocation to resolve.
Types of structural unemployment:
- Regional unemployment - Occurs when specific areas suffer from the decline of key industries, such as reduced demand for minerals leading to job losses in mining-dependent communities.
- Technological unemployment - Automation and labour-saving innovations displace workers, for example, when self-service kiosks replace shop assistants.
- International unemployment - Jobs are lost as consumers prefer cheaper imports from abroad, affecting domestic sectors like clothing manufacturing that face global competition.
This type is linked to barriers in occupational mobility (lack of skills) or geographical mobility (inability to move to where jobs are).
Cyclical unemployment
Cyclical unemployment, also known as demand-deficient unemployment, results from a downturn in overall economic activity. It spreads across multiple sectors when aggregate demand falls, leading to widespread job cuts. Even if wages decrease, it may continue because reduced earnings further weaken consumer spending, perpetuating low demand.
Consequences of unemployment for individuals, firms, and the economy
Unemployment has wide-ranging effects that impact personal lives, business operations, and broader economic performance. These consequences can vary in severity depending on the duration and scale of the unemployment.
Effects on unemployed individuals
- Reduced earnings, which can lead to financial hardship.
- Greater challenges in securing new employment as time out of work lengthens.
- Missed opportunities for skill development and keeping up with industry changes.
- Erosion of self-esteem and potential deterioration in health, both physical and mental.
- In some cases, it provides a chance to pursue more fulfilling or higher-paying roles.
Effects on firms
- Access to a larger pool of job applicants, allowing for better hiring choices.
- Increased flexibility in the workforce, as employees shift between sectors in response to market needs.
- Reduced pressure for pay rises due to workers' fears of job loss.
- Decreased demand for products and services, as unemployed people spend less.
Effects on the economy
- Wasted resources, with production falling short of the economy's full potential (opportunity cost).
- Lower overall living standards compared to what could be achieved with everyone employed.
- Decreased government income from taxes.
- Higher public expenditure on welfare payments, diverting funds from other areas like infrastructure.
The significance and implications of unemployment
The impact of unemployment depends on its level, length, and category. High rates signal an underperforming economy, while even low rates may hide underlying issues. Governments aim to manage it to promote stability and growth.
Factors influencing the seriousness of unemployment
- Rate and duration - Elevated rates show the economy operating far below capacity, often represented as being inside its production possibility curve. Prolonged periods exacerbate problems like skill erosion and health issues.
- Type of unemployment - Frictional is usually the least concerning and inevitable in a changing job market. Cyclical tends to be more severe due to its widespread nature and persistence. Structural requires targeted interventions like training programmes.
Long-term consequences of unemployment
- Ongoing low income leading to poverty.
- Mental health strain from anxiety and uncertainty.
- Reduced re-employment prospects as employers may view long-term joblessness unfavourably.
- Outdated skills making workers less competitive.
- Loss of motivation, with some individuals stopping their job search altogether.
- Increased discouragement among the workforce.
Government objectives in managing unemployment
Governments typically prioritise:
- Maximising employment levels.
- Reducing structural and cyclical forms through policies like education reforms or economic stimulus.
- Keeping frictional unemployment to a minimum without stifling job mobility.
Limitations of low unemployment figures
Low unemployment does not always reflect a healthy economy:
- It may conceal poor-quality jobs, such as low-wage or insecure positions.
- Underemployment occurs when people are in part-time roles but desire full-time work, or when they are overqualified for their jobs.
- Rates can appear lower if discouraged workers stop looking for employment and are no longer counted.
Unemployment often affects certain groups disproportionately, including specific age groups, regions, and those with particular skill sets.