6.11 - Effects of Government Policies on the Current Account
The objective of current account stability
The government aims for stability in the current account of the balance of payments, where the value of money flowing into the country matches the value flowing out. This balance helps avoid building up international debt while ensuring the country can continue buying goods and services from abroad.
Benefits and implications of current account positions
- Current account deficits - These occur when a country spends more on imports than it earns from exports. Short-term deficits can be useful for funding imports of essential raw materials or machinery that support future growth. They also allow a country to enjoy a higher level of consumption than its own production would permit.
- Current account surpluses - These happen when export earnings exceed import spending. Surpluses can increase overall demand in the economy and provide extra funds to pay off debts owed to other countries.
Fiscal policy for managing the current account
Fiscal policy involves government decisions on taxation and spending, which can be adjusted to influence the current account. Contractionary measures aim to reduce deficits, while expansionary measures target surpluses.
Contractionary fiscal policy to reduce current account deficits
Contractionary fiscal policy decreases demand in the economy to cut import spending and encourage exports:
- Raising income tax - This lowers disposable income for households, reducing their spending on imported goods.
- Cutting government spending - Reducing public expenditure directly lowers demand for both domestic and imported products.
- Encouraging exports - With weaker domestic demand, firms may focus more on selling abroad to maintain sales levels.
Expansionary fiscal policy to reduce current account surpluses
Expansionary fiscal policy boosts demand to increase imports and redirect goods from exports to the home market:
- Lowering income tax - This increases disposable income, encouraging more consumer spending, including on imports.
- Increasing government spending - Boosting areas like social benefits raises overall expenditure, leading to higher imports.
- Diverting from exports - Greater domestic demand can pull products away from foreign markets towards local buyers.
Limitations of fiscal policy
- Short-term effectiveness - It usually only provides temporary fixes, as consumer and business habits often return to normal once the policy changes end.
- Impact on employment and growth - Higher taxes can lead to job losses and slower economic expansion.
- Disincentive effects - Taxation may discourage work or investment, potentially harming the economy's overall supply capacity.
Monetary policy for managing the current account
Monetary policy controls the money supply and interest rates, which can influence exchange rates and spending patterns to affect the current account.
How monetary policy influences the current account
- Lower interest rates - These can cause a floating exchange rate to depreciate, making exports cheaper and more competitive abroad while risking inflation by increasing demand.
- Higher interest rates - These reduce consumer spending and import demand, and help control inflation. They may also strengthen the exchange rate, which could make imports cheaper.
Expansionary monetary policy to reduce current account surpluses
- Increasing the money supply - This expands available funds for spending.
- Cutting interest rates - Lower rates encourage borrowing and expenditure, which can lead to exchange rate appreciation and higher imports.
Limitations of monetary policy
Monetary policy does not tackle underlying issues like poor productivity.
Supply-side policies for improving the current account
Supply-side policies focus on enhancing the economy's productive capacity and competitiveness, which can help correct current account deficits over the long term. These policies are not typically used to reduce surpluses.
Ways supply-side policies improve the current account position
Supply-side measures make domestic goods more attractive in global markets by reducing costs and improving quality:
- Deregulation and privatisation - Removing rules and selling state-owned firms to private owners can lower production costs, making exports more price competitive.
- Education and training - Investing in skills development improves workforce efficiency and product quality, boosting export appeal.
- Attracting foreign investment - A skilled labour force and high-quality equipment can draw multinational companies, increasing productive capacity and exports.
- Investment subsidies - Government support for new technology or infrastructure encourages firms to expand output for export markets.
- Trade union reform - Changes that increase workforce flexibility allow firms to adapt quickly to global demand, supporting export growth.
Advantages of supply-side policies
Unlike fiscal or monetary approaches, supply-side reforms can provide lasting improvements to the current account by addressing root causes of imbalances.
Protectionist policies and their effects on the current account
Protectionist policies aim to shield domestic industries from foreign competition, encouraging people to buy local goods instead of imports. This can help improve the current account by reducing import levels.
How protectionist policies work
- Tariffs - Taxes on imported goods raise their prices, making domestic alternatives more appealing and shifting consumer spending away from imports.
- Effectiveness factors - These policies work best when high-quality local substitutes are available for the protected goods.
Limitations and risks of protectionist policies
- Trading bloc restrictions - Countries cannot apply these measures to partners within groups like the European Union.
- Risk of retaliation - Other nations may respond with their own barriers, harming exports.
- Reduced efficiency - Without foreign competition, domestic firms may face less pressure to innovate or cut costs.