3.4 - Economies & Diseconomies of Scale
The concept of economies of scale
Economies of scale describe the cost benefits that businesses gain when they expand their production in the long term. As output increases, the average cost per unit typically decreases, allowing firms to operate more efficiently and competitively.
Types of economies of scale:
- Internal economies - These arise from improvements within the business itself.
- External economies - These come from factors outside the individual business.
Internal economies of scale and cost reduction
Internal economies of scale happen when a business's own growth leads to lower average costs through better organisation and resource use. These advantages help larger firms produce goods more cheaply than smaller ones.
Technical efficiencies
Big firms can invest in advanced machinery and production lines that cut costs per unit. Workers can focus on specific tasks, boosting productivity. The law of increased dimensions also applies: doubling the size of a structure like a warehouse increases its surface area by four times but its volume by eight times, providing more capacity per unit of building cost. This principle extends to transport, where larger ships carry more cargo at a lower cost per item.
Other internal economies of scale
- Purchasing power - Larger businesses buy raw materials in bulk, often securing lower prices from suppliers who value their custom.
- Managerial specialisation - Expanding firms hire experts for areas like finance or operations, leading to smarter decisions without costs rising in line with output.
- Financial advantages - Banks view big firms as safer bets, offering loans at reduced interest rates.
- Risk diversification - Large businesses spread operations across products and regions, making demand more stable and allowing them to handle flops in one area through successes elsewhere.
- Marketing benefits - Fixed costs like advertising are divided over more units, reducing the expense per item. Strong brands build consumer trust, cutting the need for constant promotion.
Law of increased dimensions
The law of increased dimensions illustrates how costs per unit fall with size.
| Tank | Dimensions (m) | Surface area (m2) | Volume (m3) | Cost per m3 of storage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tank A (small) | 1 x 2 x 3 | 22 | 6 | Higher per unit |
| Tank B (large) | 2 x 4 x 6 | 88 | 48 | Lower per unit |
Doubling dimensions multiplies surface area (and material costs) by four, but volume (capacity) by eight, lowering the overall cost per unit of storage.
External economies of scale and their influence on industries
External economies of scale benefit all firms in a sector or area due to broader developments. These reduce costs through shared advantages, often encouraging businesses to cluster together.
Examples of external economies of scale:
- Skilled workforce development - Nearby colleges provide training suited to local industries, lowering the need for firms to spend on employee skills.
- Improved infrastructure - The presence of major businesses can prompt upgrades to roads or transport systems, aiding everyone in the region.
- Shared facilities and suppliers - Firms in the same field can pool resources like research labs, while suppliers moving closer cut delivery expenses.
Diseconomies of scale and their challenges
Diseconomies of scale occur when a business grows too large, causing average costs per unit to rise due to inefficiencies. These can be internal, stemming from the firm's own operations, or external, linked to industry-wide issues.
Internal diseconomies of scale
- Resource wastage - In big operations, materials may be lost or overused.
- Communication issues - As organisations expand, sharing information becomes harder, which can lower staff motivation and efficiency.
- Loss of control - Managers struggle to oversee everything, leading to mistakes.
- Coordination problems - Aligning different teams gets tougher, fostering divisions where departments focus on their own goals over the company's.
External diseconomies of scale
- Higher input prices - Growing demand from an expanding industry can push up the cost of raw materials.
- Supply limitations - Bulk buying might require sourcing from distant suppliers, increasing transport expenses if local options run out.
The relationship between high fixed costs and market structure
Industries with substantial fixed costs but minimal variable costs offer major economies of scale, which can transform how markets operate and who survives in them.
Effects of high fixed costs on industries:
- Cost structure changes - Heavy investments in technology, like robotic factories, raise fixed costs but slash variable ones such as labour. This makes large-scale production highly efficient.
- Competitive pressures - Firms that scale up can lower prices, gaining market share and potentially driving out rivals unable to match the efficiencies.
- Market concentration - Over time, this leads to sectors controlled by a handful of big players or even a single dominant firm, as smaller competitors close or merge.